Critical review of outliers. Why Malcolm Gladwell Thinks We Have Little Control Over Our Own Success 2019-01-11

Critical review of outliers Rating: 4,4/10 700 reviews

Outliers Chapter 1: The Matthew Effect Summary & Analysis from LitCharts

critical review of outliers

It starts off with a bang, as he discusses amateur hockey teams and how it was noticed that virtually all the players on an Under-18 hockey team came from the first three months of the year. Gladwell attempts to prove while individual efforts are a big role in success, theses outliers would have never been as… genetic combinations which are optimal for surviving and thriving. Their stamina and talent are at the highest level possible. That is going to make them look like they are better players than you are — and they will be too. Using studies, Malcolm seeks to prove that the level of training that leads to mastery is around 10,000 hours. He says that the timing of birth is a factor and I certainly think so, but it's also because of one or two of those people born that the next big shift in society happens and I don't think that can be ruled out.

Next

Outliers Chapter 2: The 10,000

critical review of outliers

Nevertheless, you as a part of the whole should aspire and pursue progress. Just like in rice crops, they make the necessary effort, wait and adjust until harvest. In America many people believe in the concept of a hard-working individual pulling themselves up by their bootstraps and earning their success through dedication and talent. Mozart, who didn't hit his stride until ten years after he began composing. Also, luck also has an impact on your ability to achieve mastery. These examples underline one particular point; a mix of talent and hard work is the only route to glory. In the past week, I have shared Gladwell's thesis with my students.

Next

Outliers Chapter 2: The 10,000

critical review of outliers

The solution might be a little too neat, but the Irish, particularly the Northern Irish, are far too likely to feuds that are intractable and recognising that that might have cultural roots beyond the excuse of religion is utterly fascinating to me. Your Health Is Not The Result Of A Healthy Life Many tend to believe that healthy people eat well, exercise, lead healthy lives, and have good genes. I wonder if it is my own paranoia, but I guessed that there is an undercurrent of anti-intellectualism in his books. The only criticism I can make is that as with most arguments, those that aren't as advantageous to his claims are left in the background a bit. Or, when discussing dyslexia, instead of claiming it might be a gift to those who have it and is certainly a gift to society, how about considering seriously the hypothesis that this kind of early life difficulty jars the course of development, adding uncertainty increasing the chances of both success and failure, though probably not in equal proportions rather than directionality. The whining and complaining attitude will get you nowhere. His answer is that we pay too much attention to what successful people are like, and too little attention to where they are from: that is, their culture, their family, their generation, and the idiosyncratic experiences of their upbringing.

Next

Outliers PDF Summary

critical review of outliers

If you have kids, read this book — it will give you hints on how to bring them up with perhaps a modest sense of entitlement — it could make all of the difference. By the time they become teenagers, their random initial advantage has turned into a real one. I have to admit to the more I think and talk about the book, the less I think of it. You already knew that, right? In the end, Gladwell doesn't explain success at all in a convincing fashion, and risks leaving the reader with the impression that fatalism is the only attitude to have towards their own success. I thought the book felt like it suffered from data mining, in that there didn't seem to be enough exploration of other equally successful groups that may not have had the same advantages. Also, I knew many people born late in the year who'd played competitive sports and had excellent careers. Hard work matters much more than raw talent.


Next

Book Review

critical review of outliers

Photo Malcolm Gladwell Credit Brooke Williams To Mr. He mentioned about observations on the birth dates of Canadian hockey players and the eligibility of children to participate in youth hockey leagues. However, after reading Tolkein, I did not venture out into the world in search of hobbits, dwarves and elves to be my new friends, or worry about being attacked by trolls. One time in particular stood out to me when trying to think of examples of how music…. The research on this issue, however, is decidedly mixed. A young boy has talent as a child, is found by a talent scout, and works hard to rise to the top of the Canadian hockey meritocracy.


Next

Outliers Analysis Research Paper

critical review of outliers

A theory of putting in ten thousand hours is discussed as the way to become an expert. But an idea that people feel like they already knew is much different from an idea people really did know all along. It was just an This was such an unexpected pleasure to listen to. If you value our work, please disable your ad blocker. Oppenheimer had acquires more of the necessary skills, had had more opportunities to practice these skills, and as a result he fared better than Langan, who never learned skills that would ultimately become of vital importance—like negotiating and navigating complicated form work—was almost destined by his childhood not to succeed. It tells the extraordinary story of child prodigy Bill Gates and his road to found one of the greatest companies in our history. While the book can be summarized in one sentence, the individual chapters are interesting such as the chapter that discusses a plane crash that happened in New York because the pilots were too subservient to make it clear to the air traffic controllers that they were almost out of gas.

Next

Malcolm Gladwell critique: David and Goliath misrepresents the science.

critical review of outliers

They have to be unique in their own way. Outliers almost paints a different picture. He is a writer for the New Yorker since 1996. For this reason, some parents hold their kids back a year from school, fearing they won't succeed. If you are a free individual, an open-minded person; this book will get the best out of you.

Next

Outliers: The Story of Success by Malcolm Gladwell

critical review of outliers

When parents are less present, children tend to feel more comfortable in different environments. Having a well-written piece of mass-market writing is just the thing I need to access this information. So is ancestry or locality responsible? In Jamaica, for example, in the 18th century, those born with lighter skin, children of white, affluent relationships with the local black population, were considered superior compared to the darker skin. Yes, is seems so, and Malcolm nicely shows how these seemingly unrelated events are tightly bound. This seemingly small fact crippled him—one imagines that, with a different childhood, Langan could have achieved much more.


Next

Outliers PDF Summary

critical review of outliers

If he is right about basketball, thousands of teams have been employing bad strategies for no good reason. It starts with a story about a town whose inhabitants only ever die from old age i. His story is one that has been heard by many that deals. The resulting transcript makes the unusual prevalence of January, February and March birthdays exceedingly clear. It is almost never just a single cause. In chapter seven, Gladwell claims that communication is an important principle to succeed professionally.

Next